Sworn in, berths claimed, security passes grinned for, offices allocated: there’s no going back. If any of the 48 new boys and girls at Holyrood had any niggling doubts about what the next five years might hold, well it’s too late now. You’re in and we’re stuck with you.
So, congratulations all and welcome. The burd looks forward to making your acquaintance in the weeks and months to come. The start of a new parliamentary session is always exciting watching the shiny new faces arrive and wondering who will be quick off the blocks to make their mark.
Over the years, far too many have allowed the size, scale and scope of the place and the role to simply swallow them up. There is an artform to keeping and looking busy which many have perfected, but it would be good if we can break that mould.
For all the hullabaloo about a lack of powers, the issues which Holyrood controls or touches upon is of a huge range. Yet, week in, week out, we hear about the same narrow faultlines. Many important matters are kept hidden under a bushel, or rather out of the limelight, by accident or design. If the burd could be so bold as to offer the new MSPs one piece of advice, it would be this: find an issue, make it your own, shine a light into dark corners, generate public and media interest, make change happen.
Aside from settling in – please don’t settle down – there’s plenty to keep the newbies busy. Who might shine and soar? Here’s the burdz ten to watch:
- Margaret Burgess, SNP MSP for Cunninghame South. Margaret managed to get herself elected as a councillor way back in the mists of time when the height of the SNP’s ambition was the odd seat at Westminster and saving deposits was all the rage. She’s been a party stalwart for years but has a rich and varied social justice hinterland in her working and personal life to call on. A Citizens Advice Bureau manager for many years, she has seen what deprivation does first hand. Holyrood needs more MSPs to articulate the impact of this recession and the difficulties that will result for many vulnerable families and groups in our society from cuts to public services. She won’t want to make waves or trouble for her leadership but is canny enough to know that there are ways and means to making herself – and the voiceless – heard. The burd for one is glad she has a berth deserving of her talents.
- Mike MacKenzie, SNP MSP for Highlands and Islands region. Made it into Holyrood by the skin of his teeth, here is someone we could all grow to like: a businessman with a social conscience. He has been a successful entrepreneur, providing much needed employment and infrastructure in the Oban area, has supported modern apprenticeships and set up a successful community social enterprise. Expect someone who thinks and sees issues differently, who is task oriented and solution focused. He may find himself frustrated by the semantics and boundaries of politics or he may find the way to cut through the crap. I hope it’s the latter. We need MSPs to offer something different.
- Jenny Marra, Labour MSP for North East Scotland region. Intelligent, talented, bright, vivacious. Yep, the girl has it all. Oh, and a USP as the niece of folk legend and Dundonian, Michael Marra. This is one wee star who will soar. Media friendly, with an intellect and the education to back it up, she may be a bit wet behind the ears and spent much of her life in the political bubble, but that’s not a detraction from her undoubted skills. Expect lots of salivating journos beating a path to her door for feature pieces. If she chooses her moments and issues carefully, she will go far.
- Marco Biagi, SNP MSP for Edinburgh Central. Gonnae say that oath in Italian again, please Marco?! Another with a ferocious intellect and the graduation certificates to back it up, Salmond referred to Marco as the party’s resident psephologist but the boy’s talents are much greater than this. A policy wonk who will have to learn fast how to transfer these skills into people ones in order to turn a surprise win into a safe hold, Marco should do very well. Here’s hoping he can orate as well as he thinks and liven up debates. Or at least just bamboozle them with knowledge. Preferably in Italian.
- Joan McAlpine, SNP MSP for South of Scotland region A high achiever by anyone’s standards. One of the few women journalists ever to edit one of Scotland’s foremost blatts, Joan also formed one half of the SNP’s most glamorous couple, when married to musician and writer, Pat Kane. Played a key role in the media team during this election campaign, she could be a contender for an early Ministerial role, something culture oriented perhaps, as Salmond is quite fond of pigeon holing folk. She should be a super soaraway star but… there is a teensy risk that the transition from journalist to parliamentarian could prove an ultimately frustrating one.
- Graeme Pearson, Labour MSP for South of Scotland region. One of the few MSPs breaking the traditional Labour mould, Pearson is a former high ranking police officer. He was the first Director-General of the Scottish Crime and Drug Enforcement Agency and as an Assistant Divisional Commander at Strathclyde, introduced the controversial youth curfew pilot in Hamilton and also the first CCTV cameras to Airdrie town centre. Yep, he’s to blame, and probably had a hand in Labour’s mandatory knife crime sentencing policy too. Expect a strident but informed voice on crime issues. If he wants a long career, he might want to think about how he can make a more thoughtful contribution to reforming our criminal justice system.
- Ruth Davidson, Conservative MSP for Glasgow. Ah, you’ve got to like a girl with boundless ambition. Two minutes in the door as an MSP and already touting herself – or at least her supporters are – as a possible leadership contender in the autumn. Whatever the rank and file think, the Tories need bright young things with a different background – TA volunteer and lesbian, no less – to start the process of detoxifying the brand. With the lamented demise of Derek Brownlee, expect Ruth to slip seamlessly into his role as media commentator. But she needs to prove there is substance to match the sizzle.
- Paul Wheelhouse, SNP MSP for South of Scotland. I’ll declare an interest – he’s a pal and few results made me happier than this one. Hardworking, loyal, quiet, thoughtful and intelligent. And that’s on a bad day. By his own efforts, he’s turned a safe Conservative constituency into one that’s on a shoogly peg, recruiting a willing team to support him in the process. These are real politician’s skills. And he’s another policy wonk: an economist with a keen understanding of further and higher education issues and if anyone was your man to lay bare the impact of PPP capital projects on the public purse, Paul is. I don’t have to hope that he will do well: I know he will.
- Alison Johnstone, Green MSP for Lothians. Well, at least Patrick got a buddy back and how nice that the Scottish Greens are perfectly gender balanced. On the surface, she seems a bit of ying to Patrick’s yang and that is another good thing. Alison’s bright, feisty, committed, telegenic, but if she wanted to ease herself into the role, she’s in for a shock. With only two players, both Greens need to be operating at full tilt from the outset. She’s definitely got something to offer and there is a niche with her name on it. She just needs to find it fast and hold to it too. Ditching the cooncil ward in 2012 will help.
- Humza Yousaf, SNP MSP for Glasgow. Well, he’s already stolen the show with that wonderful bagpipes and bhangra outfit at the sweary-in ceremony. He’s intelligent, articulate, a poster boy for new Scots, but with a refreshing honesty and confidence, as well as a good heart. His track record in community activism would shame many politicians twice his age. Humza represents all that the SNP is trying to promote to Scotland and expect him to be promoted lang and weary as a spokesperson. There’s a risk he could become ubiquitous and he’d do well to sit back for a moment and choose his course, if he doesn’t want to burn out. And not to lose his tendency to be ever so slightly off message on occasion. It’s all about standing out from that very big crowd of 69 when the moment is right. I’ll go so far as to punt him as the next but one SNP leader.
#1 by douglasmclellan on May 13, 2011 - 9:05 am
I would add Willie Rennie to that list.
#2 by Malc on May 13, 2011 - 9:58 am
I can’t speak for Kate, but I assume Willie Rennie was overlooked for the list since he’s someone we already know from his time at Westminster. In that regard, he’s not really a “new face”. But I agree – he’s one to watch. Ditto Kez Dugdale.
#3 by Keith Legg on May 13, 2011 - 9:18 am
Damn, Douglas got in first!
#4 by Zoe Smith on May 13, 2011 - 9:31 am
I would second Willie Rennie’s inclusion and also add that Kez Dugdale and Claudia Beamish could be interesting.
I think Kez’s contribution is probably likely to be most salient within the party initially but I think she has a lot to offer in areas so far unexplored by Labour and she has the drive, determination and desire to make a name for herself that could motivate some bold, interesting moves.
Claudia will bring a much needed understanding of green issues- an element we’ve not really had within Scottish Labour in Holyrood so far.
Agree with your assessment of Humza Yousaf, really one to watch.
#5 by Danny1995 on May 13, 2011 - 9:37 am
Agreed about Rennie and I’d also add Kezia Dugdale.
#6 by Doug Daniel on May 13, 2011 - 9:52 am
It’s hard to argue with any of the names on that list. I was particularly pleased Humza Yousaf got in – on election night I was worrying that the SNP would end up without any list MSPs in Glasgow due to doing too well, so it was good that he still got in.
It’s nice to see Holyrood being filled up with talented folk, especially ambitious ones – that’s ambition for doing a good job, not ambition for moving on to Westminster. The stronger the calibre of MSPs we have, the stronger our parliament becomes.
#7 by The Burd on May 13, 2011 - 6:21 pm
But whether we want it or not there needs to be a strong oppostition – it’s a prerequisite for good government really in the long term. Its absence is not a good thing for democracy and governance generally.
#8 by Gavin Hamilton on May 13, 2011 - 9:58 am
Ditto Willie Rennie.
Loads of energy – and if only because he will probably end up being LibDem leader so his profile will be raised quickly and we will be watching him.
#9 by Aidan Skinner on May 13, 2011 - 10:10 am
Jenny Marra also has good links to the London leadership, having been Scottish Organiser for Team Ed in the leadership campaign last year. Likely to do very well indeed.
As for Ruth Davidson, think you’d be hard pushed to find a harder nose or sharper elbows in the chamber. (I mean that in a nice way)
#10 by The Burd on May 13, 2011 - 6:16 pm
Aidan, I thought John Park ran Ed’s campaign in Scotland last year?
#11 by Aidan Skinner on May 14, 2011 - 10:29 am
She was running the activists like me, dealing with callsheets etc. I’m not sure what title Mr Park had but Scottish Organiser was what was on the bottom of the emails she sent me and if you can get more official than that… 😉
#12 by John Ruddy on May 13, 2011 - 7:10 pm
Dont forget she was also involved (I’m not sure if she was Scottish Chair, but something like that) of the Yes2AV campaign.
#13 by Caron on May 13, 2011 - 11:23 am
I can’t believe you didn’t put Willie in right at the start. He’s an obvious one to watch. One of the bravest people, with the best interpersonal skills I know. Not the greatest orator in the world, but he understands people.
#14 by Malc on May 13, 2011 - 11:29 am
Caron – like I say, I don’t presume to talk for Kate – but see my comment above. We know Willie, we’ve seen him before. I’ve been impressed with him before. So yes – I don’t disagree. But I think that’s Kate’s logic… though I may be totally wrong!
#15 by douglasmclellan on May 13, 2011 - 12:41 pm
Well Jeff has highlighted that is lack of Holyrood experience would is a risk for his leadership. I would argue that if that is the case then he should also be classed as a ‘newbie’.
#16 by Malc on May 13, 2011 - 2:52 pm
Its not me you have to make the case to… but I don’t really class him as a newbie. But that’s just me.
#17 by The Burd on May 13, 2011 - 6:15 pm
I agree Willie is hugely talented and one to watch but he’s about to become Lib Dem leader so that will give him plenty of space of his own for us to wax lyrical about his talents and point up his weaknesses (of course!). Which is why I kept him out of this which was an attempt not only to showcase the obvious ones to watch but some of the lesser known ones whom I think might shine. Hence too the exclusion of Kez.
#18 by Scotto Voce on May 13, 2011 - 12:22 pm
Jean Urquhart’s election pleased me more than any! If there’s any justice, she’ll be Culture Minister… more ‘hinterland’ than most, she’s my ‘one to watch’. And already impressed with Ruth Davidson.
#19 by The Burd on May 13, 2011 - 6:13 pm
Agreed wholeheartedly. Jean Urquhart is a fabulously talented, gifted and energetic woman who would make a wonderful cultural Minister.
#20 by Andrew on May 13, 2011 - 2:34 pm
Ruth Davidson? Well OK as long as she ditches that LAUGH. She used to be on BBC GMS as a presenter and when she let loose with that LAUGH I nearly choked in my porridge.
Calm down dear, we don’t want to see your dental work in close-up.
#21 by The Burd on May 13, 2011 - 6:12 pm
I can’t remember how she laughs – can’t wait to hear it now!
#22 by Allan on May 13, 2011 - 7:05 pm
I’m now intrigued too… hope its as good as Aleshia Dixon’s…
#23 by douglas clark on May 13, 2011 - 2:42 pm
What was quite surprising, to me at least was this:
“Humza Yousaf, SNP MSP for Glasgow. Well, he’s already stolen the show with that wonderful bagpipes and bhangra outfit at the sweary-in ceremony. He’s intelligent, articulate, a poster boy for new Scots, but with a refreshing honesty and confidence, as well as a good heart. His track record in community activism would shame many politicians twice his age. Humza represents all that the SNP is trying to promote to Scotland and expect him to be promoted lang and weary as a spokesperson. There’s a risk he could become ubiquitous and he’d do well to sit back for a moment and choose his course, if he doesn’t want to burn out. And not to lose his tendency to be ever so slightly off message on occasion. It’s all about standing out from that very big crowd of 69 when the moment is right. I’ll go so far as to punt him as the next but one SNP leader.”
I thought that was so over the top.
Then I discovered his dress sense included the world famous Partick Thistle Tartan.
Where can you get a bet on?
#24 by The Burd on May 13, 2011 - 6:12 pm
You are perfectly entitled to disagree Douglas! My thoughts only, no one else’s. But that commitment to the Jaggies tartan won you over huh?!
#25 by AliMiller on May 13, 2011 - 6:16 pm
I think this article could have easily been “20 one’s to watch” such is the apparent level of talent that has been swept in.
As others have said, Kezia Dugdale and Willie Rennie are other bright prospects. I would like to add Derek MacKay (youngest Scottish councillor when elected I think and has been impressive as Leader of Renfrewshire Council), Bill Walker (Engineer with wide international business experience) and Colin Beattie (successful in the Fincial Services Industry).
I am very hopeful that the new batch of MSPs will really improve the Scottish Parliament and Society. Labour has bemoaned the loss of Kerr, MacCabe, MacAveety, Gordon ect but I cant help but feel that – although good political operators – these very undiverse kind of people kept the parliament back.
#26 by The Burd on May 13, 2011 - 6:29 pm
I agree re the 20 and also about the 3 you mention. There are plenty to watch and see which is great. And agree wholeheartedly about the ones who got defeated. But… there always is!…. the SNP are carrying an awful lot of dual mandate councillors in the new pack. Not sure how that will play out.
#27 by Allan on May 13, 2011 - 7:12 pm
I never thought MacKay was that great as Council leader. Was impressed at the hustings event I attended though (I did wonder why he didn’t front up a lot more over the past 4 years, to explain the council’s decisions – as opposed to the column in the PDE). He was interested in answering every point put to him, even the ones put by the Labour rent-a-mob that sat at the end of my row. Interestinglty enough the Lib Dem candidate Andrew Page thought that Stuart Clark would win the seat, so made some comments about wasted non Labour votes.
#28 by Andrew on May 13, 2011 - 6:22 pm
17 The Burd
Apart from the teeth, it’s a full machine-gun staccato for more seconds than upwith I can put.
Perhaps now she’s an Emespee she’ll be quieter…..
Good luck to her anyway.
#29 by Lost Highlander on May 13, 2011 - 11:27 pm
John Finnie Highland Regional MSP has done very well up here and definitly worth watching too.
#30 by The Burd on May 14, 2011 - 8:53 am
Agreed – he was one I dithered over including but to keep it at barely readable length I limited it to 10. In a 20 he would definitely have made it. The beauty of these lists is that none of us agree!
Will revist this I think in 6 months to see who has made their mark, which will be interesting!
#31 by douglas clark on May 14, 2011 - 5:12 am
The Burd @ 22,
I didn’t disagree with you as such. Just found your final sentence a bit surprising and uplifting even.
I’d really like to see that happening. It would tell the lie to what the SNP are all about. As Humza Yousaf has said, IIRC, he stands for civic nationalism which is my point of reference too.
I was just joking about the PTFC association. Though I was heartbroken to know that he just liked the colour scheme 😉
#32 by douglas clark on May 14, 2011 - 5:17 am
Oops, The Burd @ 23 even.