This story may well shock you as much as it shocked me. I had always assumed it was the stuff of sci-fi, an Orwellian nightmare but ‘Tesco-towns’ are apparently on their way. It is a concept that will take some selling; perhaps a catchy jingle (‘aisle be there for you’) or whizzy gadgetry with one’s Clubcard able to open the door to your flat but, however it is packaged up, barcoded and rammed into our communities, I like to think there will be protests to be had.
I make no secret of nor apology for my deep distaste for Tesco despite ceding that I probably go a bit overboard, and also fully accept that free markets and a Capitalist system will inevitably lead to the biggest companies with the strongest financial muscle being able to boss their particular markets. One of the main problems, though, is that Tesco seems unable to stay within its traditional marketplace. World domination beckons and, to that unblinking end, every little extra product helps. After all, with Tesco you can bank, post, get a new phone, buy your clothes, get a credit card, process photos, take out a Tesco mortgage (to pay for your Tesco home), take out a loan for a car, get car insurance and fill it up with Tesco petrol and so much more, all for cheaper than most other competitors thanks to the organisation’s crushing economies of scale.
Many take a fairly laissez-faire approach to this state of affairs, which is their right of course, but it’s important to remember that it’s our country and it’s not a case of anything goes for towns, villages and communities the country over.
It is this people power that I hope will prevent too many Tesco-villes from sprouting up. Well, that and a decent solution to the housing shortages we face either side of the border.
These mini-villages of apartments, schools and parks ‘shackled’ to the depressingly homogenous Tesco stores that are being planned across the UK come at the worst time. With the shortage of housing blighting the country at the moment, many families will have little choice but to have large supermarkets as their nearest neighbour and noisy delivery lorries as their early morning wake-up call. The Good Life it ain’t. What would Wurzel Gummidge say?
This is a map of Tesco stores in London from 2008:
It is a busy smattering of outlets that could be replicated up and down the UK and, right now, there are 21 protests against new Tesco stores in Scotland alone. The marvellous Tescopoly website can provide more detail if desired.
There are some lovely villages, inside and outside of big cities, that make do just fine without large supermarkets hoovering up the trade in everything from televisions to microwaves and from fast-food dinners to booze. These need to be the template for future plans going forward – vibrant high streets with a pulse, a life, a character that Tesco from Cheshunt cannot provide.
And here is where my protest falls down and, to add insult to injury, David Cameron’s rhetoric makes sense. No-one is forcing people to go into Tesco stores. Its popularity is not due to some odious conspiracy that I would like to think exists, but because the supermarket chain is, well, popular. I could make the point that that popularity is artificial because we all work such long hours that we have little choice come 7:30pm/8pm but to go to the only place that is open to buy our dinner and I could also claim that it is the biggest superstores that will go on getting bigger because they can keep prices lower than the fledgling competition out there but, hey, that’s capitalism for you. I’d shop at a Butchers, Bakers and even a Candlestickmakers if they stayed open past 5pm but they don’t so it is to the big superstores that I go.
David Cameron has called continuously for entrepreneurs and while most, myself included, would immediately think of manufacturing or technology with such a call, perhaps it is the more bread and butter areas of simply getting your daily shopping in where we need to think afresh. Can I complain about Tesco if I’ve not bothered my behind to help chip away at its dominant market share? Well, obviously I can (witness the above) but that’s the easy way out.
We do live in a free world and I fully accept that large megastores are an unavoidable byproduct of that appropriate way of life but my concern is that, with strong, vibrant communities largely a thing of the past and many micro-populations unable or uninterested in joining together and deciding how they want their high street to be, either through purchase power or planning processes, then many of us will be worse off.
Tesco-towns, if they do bring their American-style presence to the UK, could be described as many things but I suspect ‘idyllic’ won’t be one of the applicable adjectives. This is a shame but it is up to us, the meatballs are in our court.
#1 by indy on December 11, 2010 - 9:46 am
I agree in principle but Tesco or Asda can be an absolute godsend to people on a low or limited income. Fresh fruit and veg at affordable prices, household goods at affordable prices, kids clothes – especially school uniforms – that are amazing value. Yes it’s all unethical but, if you are struggling to get by, ethical shopping is a bit of a luxury. I know it shouldn’t be that way but it is.
Doesn’t mean I like Tesco or Asda though. They make huge profits and should be made to pay more in tax.
#2 by Douglas McLellan on December 11, 2010 - 10:22 am
You have a point Jeff but we have no-one to blame but ourselves in many respects. We have decided what we want to buy and how we want to buy it and the superstores have responded.
Of course, this is not the case in other countries. In France, your average corner-shop sells produce that is only replicated in Waitrose or specialist delis in this country. And are open till 9pm at least. Their bakeries are open very early in the morning and the better ones have queues waiting as the door opens. In fact, shop opening hours are generally longer in France (which the 2 hour lunch break might facilitate. And, generally, they stock better produce.
But we like Tesco. Or at least, as you say, have no other option due to the late afternoon closing times. My big bugbear is weekday afternoon closing (Wednesday where I am) which means I have to fit a number of things in like hair cuts, visits to the post-office and bank, volunteering etc in at weekends which means I good shopping on weeknights to the only places that are open – the supermarkets.
Two further observations. I used to live in Gorgie in Edinburgh and it used to be a great community with good local shops including a butcher, fishmonger, cobbler and family owned corner shops. They all died following the introduction of Greenways.
Finally, are the Tesco & Asda villages not just a re-interpretation of the old Mill/Company Towns? Instead of workers we are now just shoppers.
#3 by James on December 11, 2010 - 11:59 am
The latest residents of Tescoville in Edinburgh are those living around Parliament and Dumbiedykes. After about a year the Holyrood Rd supermarket (well, it’s a small one – midi perhaps) has reopened as a Tesco.
Previously I’ve wondered where to get any kind of fresh veg in the area. The choices are dismal. You can go up to the Clerk St Tesco, or get a green pepper and an onion at the top of St Mary’s St. You could trek through the park to the Sainsbury’s at Meadowbank. There are loads of good fruit and veg shops at the top of Leith Walk, especially the Asian ones, but that’s a haul too. There’s also a wee mini-market right in the middle of Dumbiedykes, but it’s better for Pot Noodles than potatoes.
Sorry for the digression. I’m as anti-Tescopoly as the next man, probably more so, but the rest of the market has failed the people who live between Holyrood Road and the Pleasance, so in this case, I was pleased. However much I might like an organic and local shop, they can now get a much better choice of food locally, even a better choice of Pot Noodle. Depressingly, this one’s progress, even though most are not.
I almost blogged about this issue too, but this is better 😉
#4 by Douglas McLellan on December 11, 2010 - 12:18 pm
I was giving this some more thought.
I live out in Penicuik at there is a local Tesco which I use. But I also shop in ‘local shops’ in Peebles and I have also shopped at the Whitmuir Organic place which is in the middle of nowhere on the A701. Again though, they are only available to me when I have the time.
There is this issue about how far we are willing to travel for our food as well. Earthy Foods in Edinburgh is just 10 minutes walk from the Meadows but most people only want to drive to it.
#5 by NoOffenceAlan on December 11, 2010 - 1:11 pm
It’s not as one-sided as you make out, Jeff.
Here in Linwood we can’t wait for the planned Tesco to open and re-generate our delapidated ‘town centre’.
#6 by Dubbieside on December 11, 2010 - 2:52 pm
Business does the following,
It sells products people want to buy.
It sells these products at prices people can pay.
It stays open so people can shop at the time that it is convenient to them.
It should therefore be no surprise that these businesses are successful and more people want them.
We used to have I think six Coop branches in this town, now we have none because they failed miserably at the points above.
#7 by Observer on December 11, 2010 - 8:58 pm
You are late to this one Jeff Tesco towns have been on the radar for some time.
It makes me think of the Stepford Wives for some reason, or that film the Village of the Damned with the weird children. Or Pod people, you get my drift.
Who would volunteer to live in a company town – that is spooky, but hey it’s a triumph of the capitalist system in action if people do.
I won’t be moving in & I guess you won’t either.
#8 by j wales on December 11, 2010 - 10:03 pm
Will housing developments by Tesco be worse than the serried rabbit hatches built by ‘proper’ building firms, or the countless grey souldestroying estates built by councils? Possibly. I do know that Tesco are very good at what they do – they replaced a Scotmid near me and the service and quality was so much better.
#9 by Dubbieside on December 12, 2010 - 10:49 am
You should not knock the company towns, they were built to fill a need for decent housing when what was then affordable was very poor.
Prime examples are Levers at Port Sunlight, Reckitts at Hull and Cadbury in the Midlands.
People were desperate to get these houses for their families. As with much today the concept of company housing appears strange now, but when they were built people generally staying with the same company all their working lives, so the fear of losing their house was not as great then as it would be today.
Pingback: The winter wonderland, tuition fees and wikileaks Edition – Scottish Roundup
#10 by Erchie on December 12, 2010 - 4:56 pm
I know that talking to the guy who works in the Glasgow Lupé Pintos that people travel from Edinburgh to the Glasgow branch because they can park near the Glasgow one. Which seems deranged to me. It’s not as if the Edinburgh one isn’t near to a bus route or walkable from the Edinburgh city centre