Due to a very busy schedule yesterday evening (chiefly involving a business Lord and eight entertaining contestants), I never did get to see the Holyrood battle over SvR. Given that probably keeps me in line with the majority of Scots and there’s little else to be said on the matter, I’m not going to worry too much about it (particularly as my chance to view it tonight is scuppered by going to watch Andy Murray at the O2!)
I am concerned however about the noises the Swinney’s problems will have consequences for the budget. That’s a dark road where only trouble and strife may lie, for the Parliament and Scotland as a whole. Ironically, it is Patrick Harvie, the only party leader who actually wanted to use the tax-varying powers, who has made the clearest call from amongst the Opposition parties to move on from the issue and look forward afresh. Iain MacWhirter is in delightfully scathing mode about the petty games being played –
““The greatest act of political sabotage since devolution,†according to Andy Kerr. Get a life.†Indeed.
There’s a pattern in business that many like to employ where you do a bit of planning, do a lot of work and then stop and ‘take stock’. I reckon that’s the stage that the Scottish Parliament should be approaching, if not today on the highly-charged First Minister’s Questions, then at least Friday or over the weekend.
Scotland has an economy that is lagging behind the rest of the UK, unemployment going up when the rest of the UK’s is going down, a huge opportunity with renewable energy if it can just find some investment capital, a big decision to make over how the next generation of graduates is funded, a growing reputation as a tourism hot-spot and a huge looming debate over how it funds its devolved self. I’ve no doubt only scratched the surface of where Scotland is and what it should be talking to itself about but I do hope I’ve at least made the point that SvR should be way, way down the list of priorities.
Let’s just hope that, against the backdrop of a nerve-jangling election contest, enough MSPs can push beyond partisan temptations and deliver a top drawer financial plan for the year ahead that will stand us in good stead for the next parliamentary term to come. More back-scratching and less back-stabbing.
There’s no avoiding a budget being quid pro quo, but it shouldn’t be tit-for-tat.
(I can’t speak for my fellow editors but I suspect this’ll be my last post to touch on SvR)
#1 by Erchie on November 25, 2010 - 1:04 pm
Looking forward to a lively discussion on Green policies.
Keep up the good work!
And a hug to James who may be feeling in need of some love lately
#2 by James on November 25, 2010 - 1:08 pm
I suspect very funny sarcasm there, but no worries on my account either way.
#3 by Erchie on November 25, 2010 - 1:57 pm
No, no sarcasm, a gentle ribbing via the “hug” comment, but trying to bring it down again like Jeff had started.
There is not enough public airing of Green issues, and I’ll admit my own ignorance of the details your policies, even though I have a Green Councillor in my street, so yes. I look forward to some discussion of issues and policies, and the Green persepective on what is going on
#4 by Jeff on November 25, 2010 - 2:06 pm
I agree Erchie, I keep trying to think of something to write on Green issues but I confess I don’t actually know of many!
More research required I suppose. There was an interesting article in the CITY AM this morning saying that if we all painted our roofs white then we’d do a lot more than some other initiatives out there (as light colours reflect heat). Sounds like a blank canvas for neds and their spray paints to me though…..!
#5 by Tormod on November 25, 2010 - 4:46 pm
The complicit media coverage in the whole affair would be enough to make a third world dictator blush.
Andy Kerr, Ian Gray and Tavish Scot:-
Paid £12m to HMRC and didn’t inform parliament.
Entererd into an SLA for £50,000 PA and didn’t inform parliament
Mothbolled SVR in 2000 and didn’t inform parliament.
I would have thought this information would have been highlighted by the MSM as hypocrisy, but I am not that naive I have followed Scottish politics enough to ken differently.
Look at the editiorials of the MSM in Scotland, it stinks but it just shows how many folk in Scotland are still on bended knee to unionism.
#6 by Tormod on November 25, 2010 - 4:57 pm
The great thing about the budget is that it makes the opposition put up or shut up.
Labour “We want Garl”
SNP “Put an admendment and say how you pay for it”
Labour “Boo SNP bad, anti-Glasgow” etc etc etc.
It will probably take Derek Brownlee / Patrick Harvie both of whom I have a great deal of time for, to make the sensible approach from the opposition